Vanessa Irenuma - View Point https://1stattorneys.ng/articles Sat, 18 Nov 2023 15:07:12 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/cropped-1a-32x32.jpg Vanessa Irenuma - View Point https://1stattorneys.ng/articles 32 32 REAL ESTATE AND PROPERTY LAW IN NIGERIA https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/18/real-estate-and-property-law-in-nigeria/ https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/18/real-estate-and-property-law-in-nigeria/#respond Sat, 18 Nov 2023 15:07:12 +0000 https://1stattorneys.com/articles/?p=3377

By Vanessa Irenuma

 Real estate and property law in Nigeria encompasses the legal framework and regulations governing the acquisition, use, ownership, and transfer of real property within the country. It plays a crucial role in ensuring the security of property rights, promoting land development, and resolving disputes related to real estate. Here’s an overview of key aspects of real estate and property law in Nigeria:

 

1.     Land Tenure System:

a.     Customary Land Tenure: Nigeria operates a dual land tenure system, which includes customary land tenure and statutory land tenure. Customary land tenure is governed by traditional or customary laws and varies from one region or community to another. It often involves communal ownership and allocation of land by traditional rulers or chiefs. In Nigeria, diverse customs and tradition regulate ownership of land from private personal to family and communal ownership. Ownership of land is generally vested in the village, community or family with the head holding it for the use of the whole village, community or family respectively. Individual right is limited to use and enjoyment of a portion of the land allocated to them. Alienation without the consent of other members is invalid because absolute ownership is vested in the community, village or family as the case maybe. The head-man is a caretaker in a representative capacity.

 

b.     Statutory Land Tenure: Statutory land tenure, on the other hand, is regulated by federal and state laws. It includes land owned by the government, public land, and land acquired under statutory rights. The land tenure system is the process of granting ownership of land to individuals, legal bodies, corporate bodies, and natural bodies based on their use of these land. This statutory instrument is used to ensure that human habitats are safe and sustainable.

 

2.     Land Registration:

a.     Land Titles: In Nigeria, there are various types of land titles, including the Certificate of Occupancy (C of O), Right of Occupancy (R of O), Deed of Assignment, and others. These titles determine the legal rights of the property owner. In Nigeria, you need a number of land titles and other documents before you can buy land or property. Land titles are legal papers that says who owns a certain piece of land or property. On the other hand, land documents are things like a receipt, invoice, contract of sale, survey, deed of assignment and allocation that you get after you buy land.

 

(1)    Certificate of Occupancy [C of O]: it is a document given out by the state government that shows that someone owns land. Without a certificate of occupancy, your land or property can be taken from you at any time without paying you anything.

 

(2)    Right of Occupancy [R of O]: It is the legal right of a person or group to live on or use land in a way that is allowed by the Land Use Act. The R of O title gives a person, a group, or a business the right to use a piece of land in a way that the government has approved.

 

b.    Land Use Act: The Land Use Act of 1978 vests all land within the territory of each state in the governor of that state, making the governor the trustee of the land on behalf of the people. Individuals and entities can obtain rights of occupancy or leases from the government through the issuance of certificates of occupancy. The implication of this act affects only landowners. Landowners need to acquire a Certificate of Occupancy, generally known as C of O, which the State Governments of the land will issue as evidence of a right of occupancy. This right of occupancy is granted to individuals to occupy, develop and use the ground for a period not exceeding 99 years. This means all the rights you have for this land are a lease, In a situation whereby a developed residential building was revoked according to Section 33 of the Land Use Act, the Governor has the discretionary right to offer resettlement instead of compensation. And if a person accepts resettlement, his right to compensation will be considered to have been fully satisfied, and no further balance shall be paid to such person. This only implies that the State Governors may have unlimited power over the land use.

 

Which just means the government may take your land anytime. The Land Use Act empowers the state Governor or the Local Government to revoke a right of Occupancy if your land is needed by the Federal, State, or Local Government for the Public Purpose of the country. According to the Land Use Act, in the case whereby a right of Occupancy is revoked, the occupier ad the holder shall be entitled to compensation for the value as the land was cancelled.

 

In a situation whereby a developed residential building was revoked according to section 33 of the Land Use Act, the Governor has the discretionary right to offer resettlement instead of compensation. And If a person accepts resettlement, his right to compensation will be considered to have been fully satisfied, and no further balance shall be paid to such person. This only implies that the State Governors may have unlimited power over the land use. An individual is entitled to no more than a half hectare (1.25 acres) of undeveloped land within a State. However, in rural areas, the country’s customary grant of land is limited to 5,000 hectares for grazing and 500 hectares for agricultural

 

3.     Property Transactions:

a.               Sale and Purchase: Property transactions in Nigeria involve the sale and purchase of land, buildings, or both. These transactions are subject to various laws, including the Conveyancing Act, which governs the transfer of property, and the Stamp Duties Act, which regulates the payment of stamp duties on property documents. A contract of sale of land is an agreement whereby the vendor promises to sell and the purchaser to buy the land in question. It is a binding agreement that the courts will enforce if necessary. The most important significance of this agreement is that it allows the purchaser ample time to investigate the title of the vendor. The parties to the transaction are Vendor and Purchaser. The Vendor’s solicitor is to prepare the Formal Contract of Sale of Land.

 

b.              Land Use Act Compliance: It’s essential for buyers and sellers to ensure that property transactions comply with the Land Use Act and other relevant laws. This often requires obtaining the necessary land titles and approvals from the appropriate authorities. Upon a satisfactory due diligence by the parties and consensus on the transaction costs, completion of the real estate transaction includes preparing and execution of the relevant documents which depend on the nature of the transfer transaction. The usual documents are Sale and Purchase Agreement, Deed of Assignment or Deed of Lease or Sublease and Power of Attorney (optional). The application form for Consent of the Governor (or Minister for Federal Government owned titles) signed by the seller or lessor is a mandatory requirement. Upon execution of the relevant documents and transfer of possession of the property to the purchaser or lessee, the process for obtaining consent of the Governor (or Minister for Federal Government land interests) and registration of the transfer of interests should commence subject to payment of the applicable taxes and fees.

 

4.     Land Use and Development:

a.     Planning and Zoning Laws: Urban and regional planning laws in Nigeria regulate land use and development. These laws define permissible land uses, zoning regulations, building codes, and environmental standards. Compliance with these regulations is crucial for property developers. In Nigeria, land use, planning, and zoning matters are residual matters in the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended) and regulated under specific legislations promulgated by the respective State’s Houses of Assembly of the 36 states and the National Assembly for the planning and zoning matters in the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja (1).The various states in Nigeria have enacted their own Physical Planning Laws which were adapted from the Federal Act (the Nigerian Urban and Regional Planning Act No. 88 of 1992 (as amended by the Urban and Regional Planning Act No. 18 of 1999) with necessary in Lagos is the Lagos State Urban and Regional Planning and Development (Amendment) Law 2019. Generally, the conditions for the grant of a development permit by the Control Department must conform to the conditions of use stated in the title document or grant of the right of Occupancy for the land in question. In the dynamic landscape of Nigeria’s growing economy, potential investors are seeking opportunities to maximize their returns and contribute to the country’s development. Among the key factors that can significantly impact investment outcomes is an understanding of land zoning and land use planning. In this article, we will explore the importance of land zoning and planning in Nigeria, and why potential investors should be aware of its implications. Land zoning and planning play a vital role in shaping the physical and economic landscape of Nigeria. These processes involve dividing land into different zones based on designated purposes, such as residential, commercial, industrial, agricultural, and recreational areas. The primary goal is to optimize land use, ensure efficient resource allocation, and create sustainable and vibrant communities.

 

b.    Building Permits: Property owners and developers must obtain building permits from the relevant local government authorities before commencing construction or renovation. A building permit is an official approval to proceed with a construction project. It is also intended to ensure that the project plans comply with local standards for land use, zoning and construction. These standards are intended to ensure the safety of current and future owners and occupants and enforcement of zoning and land use policies. Specific issues the building permit process may address include structural integrity, zoning, sanitation, water and sewer lines, fire resistance and electrical services. Permits ensure that construction is performed in compliance with state and local codes, including safety standards. … Failure to obtain a building permit is a violation of Contractors License Law. It should be noted that Building control regulations within Nigeria are within the control of State and Local Governments and they vary from state to state. In Lagos state the grant of Building permits is governed specifically by the Lagos State Physical Planning Permit Regulations 2019 and is enforced by a number of Regulatory agencies that include the following:

 

                                                    i.     The Lagos State Physical Planning Permit Authority (LASPPA) under the Ministry of Physical Planning &Urban Development,

1.     The Lagos State Lands Bureau,

2.     The Ministry of Environment,

3.     The Lagos State Building Control Agency (LASBCA).

 

5.     Property Rights and Ownership:

a.     Co-ownership: Property can be jointly owned by multiple individuals or entities. The legal structure of co-ownership should be clearly defined to prevent disputes. Property that is acquired or owned jointly by two or more individuals is said to be co-owned legally. In Nigeria, co-ownership of a property by two or more people is permitted in at least four different ways: joint tenancy, tenancy in common, tenancy by the entirety, and family ownership. When property is owned by co-owners as joint tenants, it means that each joint tenant is an equal owner of the entire property and has the right to possess the entire property. No co-owner has a separate stake in the property or part of ownership. No shared renter may claim ownership of any real estate. No joint tenant may dispose of any portion of the property without the other tenants’ approval or without first severing the joint tenancy since the joint tenants maintain their interest in undivided shares and are considered to be one single owner in the eyes of the law.

 

b.     Mortgages: Property can be used as collateral for loans or mortgages. Mortgage transactions are regulated by the Mortgage Institutions Act and the Land Use Act. A Mortgage (sum of money) is the transfer of ownership of a property (home) as security to a lender (Mortgage Bank), under the express or implied condition that the property (home) will be re-transferred to the borrower (home-owner), upon repayment of the mortgage. Section 1 [1] of the mortgage act state that No mortgage business shall be transacted in Nigeria except by a company which is duly incorporated in Nigeria for that purpose and in possession of a valid license granted by the Minister authorizing it to do so.

 

6.     Dispute Resolution:

a.     Land Disputes: Land and property disputes are common in Nigeria. They may involve conflicting claims to ownership, boundary disputes, or disputes related to land allocations. Dispute resolution mechanisms include litigation in the courts, traditional dispute resolution methods, and alternative dispute resolution (ADR) mechanisms such as arbitration and mediation. The occurrence of land-related disputes remains inevitable due to conflicting interests often associated with land rights. However, how these disputes are resolved remains of great interest to development scholars and policy makers alike. The degree of perceived tenure security in an ordinal scale is measured using the combined indicators of perception of occurrence of ownership dispute and the perception of not losing plot should dispute occurs.

Further, a two-stage sequence of choice of institutions for land-related dispute resolutions was constructed from the data to obtain four categories of possible resolution pathways. Partially constrained generalized ordered logit and multinomial logit models were also employed to assess the effects of plot holders’ Socio-economic and plot characteristics on perceived tenure (in)security and choice of dispute resolution pathway, respectively. Results reveal that the level of perceived tenure security decreases with increasing indicator combination and the choice of informal – informal pathway remains dominant even in the presence of legal pluralism. Policies that promote land documentation, strengthened extension services, and strengthened institutional capacities and access are envisioned to play significant roles in reducing land-related disputes and facilitating their resolution.

 

7.     Property Taxes and Duties:

a.     Property Taxes: Property owners are subject to property taxes imposed by local government authorities. The rates and collection procedures can vary depending on the location. Property tax rate in Nigeria is annually is 0.3% for recreational property, 0.4% for residential property, 0.6% for commercial property and 0.7% for others. Property taxes in Nigeria are usually levied annually by the state government with varying rates depending on the state and the location of the property within the state. The two major property taxes are governor’s consent fee and land registration fee. In Lagos (which is the economic hub of Nigeria), governor’s consent fee, land registration fees, and other levies payable to the state give rise to a total levy of 3% of the fair value of the land. Also, Right of Occupancy fee and tenement rates are chargeable by state and local government authorities.

 

b.    Stamp Duties: Stamp duties are payable on various property-related documents, including agreements of sale, lease agreements, and transfer documents. Under the Stamp Duty Act, stamp duty is payable on any agreement executed in Nigeria or relating, whatsoever, to any property situated in or to any matter or thing done in Nigeria. Instruments that are required to be stamped under the Stamp Duties Act must be stamped within 40 days of first execution. Stamp duty is chargeable either at fixed rates or ad valorem (i.e. in proportion to the value of the consideration), depending on the class of instrument. Stamp duty is imposed at the rate of 0.75% on the authorized share capital at incorporation of a company or on registration of new shares. All deposit banks and financial institutions are required to charge stamp duties of NGN 50 on every eligible transaction above NGN 10,000. There are exemptions for transactions between accounts held by the same bank customer and for salary accounts. The 2020 Finance to remove electronic transfer from the scope of stamp duty and introduced an electronic money transfer levy, which is applicable on electronic receipts or electronic transfer for money deposited in a financial institution, on any type of account. The applicable levy is NGN 50 on any transfer of NGN 10,000 or more.

 

8.     Real Estate Regulation:

a.     Regulatory Agencies: The Real Estate Industry is a massive one and it’s no wonder there are quite a number of regulatory bodies for the various professions contained in the industry. The regulatory bodies in Nigerian Real Estate include but are not restricted to the following;

                 I.          ESTATE SURVEYORS AND VALUERS REGISTRATION BOARD Of NIGERIA(ESVARBON); The Estate Surveyors and Valuers Registration Board of Nigeria (ESVARBON) is the regulatory body for controlling and setting standards for real estate and valuation practice in Nigeria. The profession gained limelight in the country when, in 1969, a group of qualified Chartered (General Practice) Surveyors formed what is known as the Nigeria Institution of Estate Surveyors and Valuers (NIESV), as a non-profit voluntary professional organization to cater for the interests of the Landed profession in Nigeria, Six years later, it was accorded Government recognition by the promulgation of the Estate Surveyors and Valuers (Registration, ETC) Decree No. 24 of 1975, now CAP III (Laws of the Federal Republic of Nigeria) 1990. By this legislation, Estate Surveyors and Valuers Registration Board of Nigeria (ESVARBON) came into being as the Regulatory Body for the profession.

 

               II.          NIGERIA INSTITUTE OF ESTATE SURVEYORS AND VALUERS (NIESV);

This Institute is involved in various practices such as valuation of interests in land and buildings for various purposes: sale, mortgage, insurance, acquisition, probate, stocks and shares, balance sheet, taxation etc., valuation of construction projects, building maintenance management, property management and development, infrastructure and facilities management, land reform, land registration, planning and analysis, construction/ project management, property inventory and audit and many more.

 

             III.          REAL ESTATE DEVELOPERS’ ASSOCIATION of NIGERIA (REDAN);

This is the principal agency of the organized private sector recognized by government and approved by the Federal Mortgage Bank of Nigeria (FMBN) – the apex mortgage lender in Nigeria – to facilitate the delivery of affordable mass housing for Nigerians. Since its formation about a decade ago, the Association has gained increased credibility and prestige. REDAN also seeks to achieve positive relations with all stakeholders connected with the housing industry including organizations, producers, providers, financiers, and landowners. The Association also strives to play an active role in the promotion of research for the development of building materials and systems, as well as standard setting for the industry.

 

            IV.          NIGERIA INSTITUTE OF TOWN PLANNERS (NITP);

The NITP is Nigeria’s leading planning body for spatial, sustainable, integrative and inclusive planning. The NITP exists to advance the science and art of planning for the benefit of the public. Planners develop long- and short-term plans to use land for the growth and revitalization of urban, suburban, and rural communities, while helping local officials make decisions concerning social, economic, and environmental problems. Because local governments employ the majority of urban and regional planners, they often are referred to as community, regional, or city planners.

              V.          ESTATE, RENT AND COMMISSION AGENTS ASSOCIATION OF NIGERIA(ERCAAN);

The Estate, Rent and Commission profession has been described as a noble one that has now formed an important aspect of the nation’s economy, considering the role of housing in any given country. This association is tasked with the need to educate, inform and train members on the ethics of the profession of agents and understand the best approach to landlords and tenants.

 

9.     Land Acquisition and Compensation:

a.      Land Acquisition: When the government acquires land for public purposes, it must follow legal procedures, including providing compensation to affected landowners. In Nigeria, every citizen possesses the right to acquire and own immovable property anywhere in Nigeria. However, the right to own immovable property, like every other right enshrined in the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended), is not total but subject to certain qualifications. Upon the enactment of the Land Use Act of 1978, all lands comprised in the territory of each state in Nigeria are vested in the governor of that state and such land shall be held in trust and administered for the use and common benefit of all Nigerians. The law of compulsory acquisition of land in Nigeria is rooted in the Nigerian Constitution that every Nigerian has the right to own private property and that such property shall not be acquired compulsorily, except in the manner and for the purposes prescribed by a law that requires both the payment of prompt compensation and compliance with the rule of law on access to the court. It is however pertinent to state that the Governor may revoke a right of occupancy over any land in the state on account of overriding public interest. Compulsory acquisition of land by the government for public purposes or overriding public interest can be in several phases as stressed by the Land Use Act 1978 such as infrastructure development, urban planning, or economic projects. Talking about overriding public interest, it means the acquisition of private individual land, by the government, for the use of the state. It must however be noted that where it is discovered that such acquisition made by the government was not for public purpose, then such acquisition may be marred.

 

10. Real Estate Investment:

Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs): Nigeria has established REITs, which allow investors to pool their funds to invest in a portfolio of income-generating real estate properties.

In conclusion, real estate and property law in Nigeria is a multifaceted and evolving field that is influenced by both customary and statutory laws. Understanding the legal framework, obtaining the correct land titles, and complying with land use and development regulations are crucial for property owners, developers, and investors operating in Nigeria’s real estate market. Moreover, effective dispute resolution mechanisms and compliance with property taxes and duties are essential elements of property ownership and investment in the country.

 

 

REFERENCES:

1.     https://realestateinlagos.com/nigerian-land-use-act-of-1978/

2.     https://www.dlapiperrealworld.com/law/index.html?t=sale-and-purchase&s=transactional-process&q=steps-in-the-transaction&c=NG

3.     https://taxsummaries.pwc.com/nigeria/corporate/other-taxes

4.     https://nigeriarealestatehub.com/regulatory-bodies-in-nigerian-real-estate/

5.     https://www.mondaq.com/nigeria/real-estate/1346648/compulsory-acquisition-of-land-in-nigeria-by-government-remedies-available-to-land-owners

 

 

]]>
https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/18/real-estate-and-property-law-in-nigeria/feed/ 0
THE PRINCIPLE OF UTMOST GOOD FAITH https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/the-principle-of-utmost-good-faith/ https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/the-principle-of-utmost-good-faith/#respond Fri, 17 Nov 2023 16:37:59 +0000 https://1stattorneys.com/articles/?p=3370

By Vanessa Irenuma

 The principle of utmost good faith, often referred to as uberrimae fidei, is a fundamental and longstanding concept in the insurance industry. It embodies the idea that both the insurer (the insurance company) and the insured (the policyholder) must act honestly and in good faith when entering into an insurance contract. This principle serves as the bedrock of insurance agreements, shaping the relationship between the two parties. This doctrine of utmost good faith has become a fundamental characteristic of insurance contract and distinguishes it from all other forms of contract. The good faith in the contract simply means that none of the parties to the contract should withhold any material information or misrepresent material facts that will help the other party in protecting it’s position under the contract. Joseph Irukwu V. Trinity Mills Insurance Broker the court held and restated the position of the law that the contract of insurance should be the one of utmost good faith, uberrimae fidei.

 

The insured at the point of applying for insurance cover is under obligation to disclose to the insurer all material facts with in his knowledge that the insurer does not know or is deemed not to know. an insurer is entitled to cast-off or avoid the insurance contract in it’s entirely where the insured is guilty of fraud, non-disclosure of material facts or misrepresentation before the contract was entered into.Tab Assurance Co. Limited V. Akwuzie Industries Nigeria Limited the court held that since the respondent contracted with the appellant in bad faith, the contract is rendered illegal, void and of no effect.

 

ELEMENTS OF THE DOCTRINE

The doctrine is premised on three fundamental elements, they are fraud, non-disclosure and misrepresentation. The effect of these element is that the parties could be deceived, can be misled and present a situation that is baseless and false.

 

1] FRAUD—A contract created with inaccurate information from intentional misinformation or fraudulent concealment may cause the contract to become voidable. Further, in the case of the provision of goods or services before the information is discovered or disclose, the misinformed party may enforce legal action. facts supplied by the insured when filling the proposal form will be considered fraudulent if the information supplied turn out to be false, and the insured knowingly presented same to the insurer to be truth, Therefore citing fraud he can validly disclaim the policy. Derry v. Peek where the court held that a proposer is guilty of fraudulent misrepresentation if he knowingly makes a false statement. The insured would also be guilty if he willfully conceals material fact within his knowledge from the insurer, which the insurer can void such contract or avoid entering into such contract. whether the contract is entered into or not the insurer is entitled to claim damages in tort of deceit and retain the premium already paid by the insured.

 

2] NON-DISCLOSURE—This contract is recognized by law that both parties should deal fairly and in good faith, there is non-disclosure where a fact relating to the risk is not made known by the party in possession of those facts to the other party. the rationale for non-disclosure is that the parties are not in an equal bargaining position and in particular the insured will usually be in possession of information about himself which is not known to the insurer and which the insurer could not reasonably ascertain. In order to balance the situation, a duty of utmost good faith is imposed on both parties, though in practice it will usually have most relevance to the insured in relation to the disclosure of his own circumstances at the time the policy is entered into. Failure to disclose it must be information within his[insured] knowledge, the fact must be material to the decision to be reached to take or not to take the risk to cover the insured. Tab Assurance Co. Limited V. Akwuzie Industries Nigeria Limited where the court rightly held that the insured was not entitled to be paid on the claim, so the betrayal of the element of good faith in the policy proved fatal against the insured interest.

 

3] MISREPRESENTATION— a misrepresentation is a false statement. In insurance, a misrepresentation is a false statement of a material fact on which the insurer relies and provides cover. The insurer does not have to prove that the misrepresentation is intentional, if a material fact is misrepresented, the insurer could choose to avoid the policy because of the violation of utmost good faith. the insurer is entitled to avoid a contract of insurance if the insured induced him to enter into the contract by misrepresentation of fact that is material to the risk to be ensured against. The onus of proof of inducement will be on the insurer to prove because he alleged the issue of inducement. For the insured to be guilty of the doctrine of utmost good faith, the following condition must be present:

 

1]the fact to be disclosed must be material to the contract.

2]it must be peculiarly within his knowledge and so full disclosure is expected from him.

 

Messrs. Century Insurance Co. Limited V. Obi Atuanya where the court held that, the insured was not guilty of non-disclosure and could not have been guilty of misrepresentation since he was not aware of the cancellation of the earlier contract of insurance as at the time he contracted the present. The insured is required not to be fraudulent in supplying facts concerning the contract. the obligation is on the insured to disclose the fact by way of statement that are true and not misrepresentation of the correct state of things. This obligation does not affect the making of statement of opinion, this is because statement of opinion is an expression of personal perception of any issue, and not an expert opinion. Akpata V. African Alliance Insurance Company Limited where the court held that at the time of the insured contracting he was not in the position to know or appreciate the critical nature of his death status because he was neither an expert nor a medical personnel so, the court refused to uphold the assertion of the insurer that the insured was guilty of non-disclosure or misrepresentation as to the insured health status. A statement made by an insured regarding any health status, is seen as a statement opinion, but when such statement is made with an existing medical report, it becomes a statement of fact and becomes a material fact that is capable of being construed against the insured.

 

 

CONCLUSION

In summary, the principle of utmost good faith is a fundamental element of insurance contracts, emphasizing the importance of honesty, transparency, and good faith throughout the insurance relationship. It helps maintain trust and fairness in the insurance industry while ensuring that both parties are fully informed and protected under the terms of the policy.

 

 

 

1.       Joseph Irukwu V. Trinity Mills Insurance Broker [1997]12 NWLR[Pt 531]11

2.      Tab Assurance Co. Limited V. Akwuzie Industries Nigeria Limited [1995]4 NWLR [Pt388]

3.       Derry V. Peek [1889]LR 14 App Cas 337

4.      ]Messrs. Century Insurance Co. Limited V. Obi Atuanya 3 PLR/1966/91 [HC-L]

5.      ]Akpata V. African Alliance Insurance Company Limited [1967]NWLR 12

 

 

]]>
https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/the-principle-of-utmost-good-faith/feed/ 0
PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE-MEDICAL MALPRACTICE https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/professional-negligence-medical-malpractice/ https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/professional-negligence-medical-malpractice/#respond Fri, 17 Nov 2023 15:42:14 +0000 https://1stattorneys.com/articles/?p=3362

By Vanessa Irenuma

  Professional negligence, also known as professional malpractice or professional misconduct, refers to the failure of a professional to perform their duties or provide services to a standard expected within their profession, resulting in harm or loss to their client or a third party. In Nigeria, professional negligence can occur in various fields, including medicine, law, engineering, accounting, and more. Legal remedies for professional negligence in Nigeria typically involve civil actions seeking compensation for damages caused by the professional’s substandard performance.

 

Our major focus on this article will be on medical malpractice, medical malpractice refers to situations in which healthcare providers, such as doctors, nurses, hospitals, or other healthcare facilities, fail to meet the standard of care expected within the medical profession, resulting in harm or injury to patients. Medical malpractice cases in Nigeria, as in many other countries, involve complex legal, ethical, and medical considerations. Here are key points to consider when discussing medical malpractice in Nigeria:

 

1. Standard of Care: Medical professionals in Nigeria are expected to adhere to a standard of care that reflects the level of competence and diligence expected within their specialty. This standard is determined by what a reasonable and prudent healthcare provider in the same field would do under similar circumstances. in other words, the accepted standard of care would be the care that you might expect to receive from an average doctor in the same field of practice under the same circumstances. The doctor medical knowledge and specialty are taken into account when determining the standard of care that should have been applied. in Nigeria the standard of care is established by the medical and dental council of Nigeria[MDCN].other bodies such as the Nigeria Medical Association and the Medical and Dental Consultants Association of Nigeria also have principles of ethics controlling their members with disciplinary measures put in place to guarantee compliance.

 

2. Common Forms of Medical Malpractice: Medical malpractice can take various forms, including misdiagnosis, delayed diagnosis, surgical errors, medication errors, birth injuries, anesthesia errors, and inadequate patient care. Each of these types of malpractice may involve different legal and medical issues. Medical malpractice is a breach of a legal duty to take care which is expected to be exercised, which result in damages. it can be said as the failure of the medical practitioner to exercise a reasonable care in the course of his duty as a professional in that field. in the case of Ojo V. Gharoro And Ors, the appellant was told by the respondent that she had a growth in her fallopian tube, to this effect, she needed surgical operations in removing the growth which she consented to. After the operation, she complained of abdominal pain, and an x-ray was carried out. It was discovered that there was a broken needle in her abdomen. It was held that the respondents exercised their best medical skills and so no medical negligence occurred. To fortify the decision, the supreme court borrowed the words of Lord Denning, In his book titled The discipline of law, wherein he opined; A medical man, for instance, should not be found guilty of negligence unless he has done something of which his colleagues would say; he really did make a mistake there. he ought not to have done it…but in a hospital, when a person who is ill goes in for treatment, there is always some risk, no matter what care is used. Every surgical operation involves risks. It would be wrong, and indeed, bad law, to say that simply a misadventure or mishap occurred, the hospital and the doctors are thereby liable. It would be disastrous to the community, if it were so. It would mean that a doctor examining a patient, or a surgeon operating at a table, instead of getting on with his work, would be forever looking over his shoulder to see if someone was coming up with a dagger for an action for negligence against a doctor is for him like unto a dagger. His professional reputation is as dear to him as his body perhaps more so, and an action for negligence can wound his reputation as severely as a dagger can his body. You must not therefore, negligent simply because something happens to go wrong…..you should only find him guilty of negligence when he falls short of the standard of a reasonably skillful medical man, in short, when he is deserving of censure.

 

3. Duty of Care: To establish a medical malpractice claim, the plaintiff (the patient or their representative) must demonstrate that the healthcare provider owed them a duty of care. This duty arises from the provider-patient relationship. Duty of care is one of the fiduciary relationships owed by the doctor to his patients. The black’s law dictionary defines fiduciary relationship as a relationship in which one person is under a duty to act for the benefit of another on matters within the scope of the relationship. ’the relationship between a doctor and his patient is one of trust and confidence; a relationship where one has the power and the duty to treat and restore the other to mental and physical wellbeing’’ this duty is a promise made by medical practitioners upon induction after going through the necessary medical training and enforced by the Hippocratic oath. In the recent case of Owoyele V. Mobil Production Nigeria Unltd established the ingredient of duty of care. The essential elements or ingredients of actionable negligence are as follows; the existence of a duty to take care owed to [a] the claimant by the defendant; [b] prescribed by law [breach of duty ], and [c] damages suffered by the claimant, which must be connected with the breach of the duty to take care. Once these ingredients are established at a hearing, the defendant will be held liable in negligence.

 

The first ingredient is required to establish that the duty of care exists between two parties and it is owed by the defendant to the claimant. It is necessary to establish because of the fiduciary relationship that exist. The second ingredient requires that duty of care owed by the claimant by the defendant must be prescribed by law or a breach of duty. The medical profession is guided by certain laws and oaths that are sworn by members of the medical profession upon completion of their training; these are laws that can be enforced against these personnel upon failure or breach. Thirdly the claimant must prove that because of this breach, he or she suffered an injury. It is trite law that he who assert must prove. Therefore, the claimant must prove that he suffered injury due to lack of exercise of duty of care by the medical practitioner. OTTI V. EXCEL- C MEDICAL CENTER LTD the court stated the principle of duty of care owed to a patient by a medical doctor or hospital. A medical doctor or a hospital owes a patient a duty of care with regard to the procedure for a medical treatment of the patient.

 

4. Breach of Duty: The plaintiff must show that the healthcare provider breached their duty of care by failing to meet the accepted standard of care. This often requires expert medical testimony to establish what the standard of care should have been in the given situation and how it was violated. Breaching the duty of care can also be called ‘NEGLIGENCE’. If a doctor negligently-as in carelessly, or irresponsibly-breached his or her duties of care to a patient and caused injury, the doctor can be responsible for damages. However, there are conditions which must be established by the aggrieved party in order to succeed in an action for negligence against a medical practitioner. Such a party must prove that;[1] the medical practitioner owed the patient a duty to use reasonable care in treating him or her [2] the medical practitioner failed to exercise such care, and he was breach of that duty;[3] the patient suffered damages or injury as a result of the breach. Such damages or injury must be a direct and not a remote consequence of the practitioner’s action. A party aggrieved by medical negligence can file a criminal complaint under criminal law or institute an action for a civil wrong. Or follow the complaint procedure provided by the Medical And Dental Practitioners Act for professional misconduct. The onus of proof lies with the aggrieved party who must provide evidence to show negligence on the part of the medical practitioner. A victim of medical negligence can file a civil action against the negligent medical practitioner by issuing a writ of summons at the appropriate court, claiming special and general damages against the medical practitioner. The criminal code provides that ‘’it is the duty of every person who, except in a case of necessity, undertakes to administer surgical or medical treatment to any other person, or to do any other lawful act which is or may be dangerous to human life or health to have reasonable skill and to use reasonable care in doing such act and he is held to have caused any consequences which result to the life or health of any person by reason of any omission to observe or perform that duty’’. The court held in R V. AKERELE where a medical practitioner who applied overdosed on a drug on a number of children, which led to their death, was held to have been criminally negligent and accordingly convicted for manslaughter.

 

CONCLUSION

Medical malpractice cases in Nigeria, like in many other countries, are complex and require a thorough understanding of both medical and legal principles. Patients who believe they have been victims of medical malpractice should seek legal representation from qualified attorneys experienced in handling such cases to navigate the legal process effectively. Patient should be aware of their right, the right to ask questions, the right to seek second opinions, the right to choose their preferred treatment option and the right to complain where treatment is unpalatable. They should also be aware of the concept of medical negligence. It is important to note that not every action or omission by a medical practitioner will lead to medical negligence, as each case would depend on its peculiarity, as an action for medical negligence requires strict proof.

 

 

]]>
https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/professional-negligence-medical-malpractice/feed/ 0
MATERIAL FACTS IN AN INSURANCE CONTRACT https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/material-facts-in-an-insurance-contract/ https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/material-facts-in-an-insurance-contract/#respond Fri, 17 Nov 2023 15:10:58 +0000 https://1stattorneys.com/articles/?p=3345

By Vanessa Irenuma

 

 MATERIAL FACTS IN AN INSURANCE CONTRACT

 

 A “material fact” in an insurance contract refers to a key piece of information or detail that could significantly influence the terms and conditions of the insurance policy. Insurance companies rely on the accuracy and completeness of information provided by the policyholder to assess risk and determine the premium, coverage limits, and terms of the policy. Failing to disclose material facts or providing false information can have significant consequences for the policyholder. Material facts can be determine by evidence, statutory or judicial interpretation or by expert opinion. A fact is considered material for the purpose of construing fraud, non-disclosure and misrepresentation, if it is a fact that would influence a reasonable insurer in deciding whether to accept or reject the risk involve in the contract or to accept or reject the premium to charge on the risk.

 

Under common law the test of materiality is that of a prudent insurer, a fact is material in the insurance policy if it is the one that would influence the underwriting judgment of a reasonable or prudent insurer. CONTAINER TRANSPORT INTERNATIONAL INC .V. OCEANS MUTUAL UNDERWRITING ASSOCIATION [BERMUDA] LIMITED  the court held that a circumstances of fact is material if it would have influenced the judgment of a prudent insurer in fixing the premium on the insurance or in determining whether he will provide insurance cover for the proposed risk. SECTION 20 (1) OF THE MARINE INSURANCE ACT state that, Subject to the provision of this section, the assured shall disclose to the insurer, before the contract is concluded, every material circumstance which is known to the assured, and the assured shall be deemed to know every circumstance which, in the ordinary course of business, ought to be known by him. The position of the common law will in fact result to hardship for the insured. The insurance act 2003 has come to the rescue in modifying the application of the rule of common law in Nigeria. SECTION 54[1] OF THE INSURANCE ACT state that where an insurer requires an insured to complete a proposal form or other application form for insurance, the form shall be drawn up in such manner as to elicit such information as the insurer consider material in accepting the application for insurance of the risk and any information not specifically requested shall be deemed not to be material.

 

With this new position of the law dealing with materiality, the onus of proving that any particular fact is material to the insurance contract lies on the insurer and where he fails to draw up a proposal form in such a manner so as to accommodate the obtaining of any information he may requires from the insured, the insurer is subsequently precluded from setting up the materiality of such fact, which was not contemplated in the proposal form, as basis for disclaiming liability on the policy. SECTION 55 [1] OF THE INSURANCE ACT which states that in a contract of insurance a breach of term whether called a warranty or a condition shall not give rise to any right by or afford a defense to the insured unless the term is material and relevant to the risk or loss insured against. The act shall not prevent an insurer from repudiating an insurance contract on the ground of a breach of a material term provided the repudiation happened before the occurrence of the risk insured against.

 

EXAMPLE OF MATERIAL FACTS the following are some of the facts that are considered material in the insurance contract:

 

1)    Previous Insurance History: the contract of insurance is contract based on utmost good faith, the insured is expected to fill all material fact when filling the contract/proposal form, especially all facts that border on moral hazards. LOCKER AND WOLF LIMITED .V. WESTERN AUSTRALIAN INSURANCE CO. LIMITED where the court held that the insured failure to disclose the previous insurance history amounted to a breach of the doctrine of utmost good faith.

 

2)    Previous Criminal History: this is because as a contract of utmost good faith.it is good for the insurer to be apprised of the previous criminal history of the proposer. this information is necessary in order for the insurer to be aware of the moral hazards of covering the risk for a person in that category but not to put the insured in any disadvantage position. Allegation of minor criminality that occurred a long time before the proposal would not be considered a material facts. SCHOOLMAN V. HALL in this case the court held that the previous criminal history of the proposal, even if it is of a dim and remote past, was material fact to the policy.

 

3)   Illness: a contract of insurance is an assurance of indemnity or compensation upon the occurrence of the peril insured against. It therefore means that when the health condition of the insured is of the essence, and so the ill health of the insured is material fact to the success of the contract and so it should be disclosed. CANNING V. FARGUHAR where the court of appeal held that the insurer was not liable under the policy on the grounds of non-disclosure of material fact relating to the ill health of the insured.

 

 

References:

 

1.      Container Transport International Inc .V. Oceans Mutual Underwriting Association [Bermuda] Limited [1982]2 Lloyd”S Rep.

2.      Locker And Wolf Limited .V. Western Australian Insurance Co. Limited (1936)1 K .B.408

3.      Schoolman V. Hall (1951)1 Lioyd’s Rep 139

4.      Canning V. Farguhar(1886)16 QBD 272

 

 

]]>
https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/material-facts-in-an-insurance-contract/feed/ 0
E-COMMERCE AND ONLINE CONTRACT IN NIGERIA https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/e-commerce-and-online-contract-in-nigeria/ https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/e-commerce-and-online-contract-in-nigeria/#respond Fri, 17 Nov 2023 12:00:45 +0000 https://1stattorneys.com/articles/?p=3326

By Vanessa Irenuma

Introduction:

E-commerce in Nigeria has experienced significant growth in recent years, driven by factors such as increased internet penetration, the proliferation of smartphones, and a growing middle class with disposable income. Online contracts are a crucial aspect of e-commerce, as they govern the terms and conditions of transactions conducted over the internet. Let’s discuss e-commerce and online contracts in Nigeria:

E-commerce in Nigeria:

1. Market Growth: Nigeria’s e-commerce sector has witnessed substantial growth, with both local and international e-commerce platforms entering the market. Some popular Nigerian e-commerce platforms include Jumia, Konga, PayPorte, and many others. Nigeria is the 40th largest market for e-commerce with a predicted revenue of US$6,653.5 million in 2023, placing it ahead of Egypt. Revenue is expected to show a compound annual growth rate[CAGR 2023-2027] of 10.8%, resulting in a projected market volume of US$10,026.9 million by 2027. with an expected increase of 14.6% this year, The Nigeria e-commerce market contributed to the worldwide growth rate of 9.6% in 2023. the online share refers to the proportion of the retail volume that is transacted via the internet. It include purchase via desktop pc, tablet or smartphone, both via website or app. Only retail of physical goods is taken into account. In Nigeria retail market, the online share is 1.6% and will decreased by an average of 0.95% to 1.6% by 2027.

2. Mobile Commerce: Nigeria has a high mobile phone penetration rate, and many consumers access e-commerce platforms through mobile devices. This has led to the rise of mobile commerce or m-commerce in the country. More Nigerians are utilizing their gadgets to make online buys with the ascent of cell phone and other cell phone. As per the national communication commission [NCC], 89% of web clients make buy on the web, with one more 24%wanting to do as such sooner rather than later.

3. Payment Systems: Payment infrastructure has improved with the introduction of various online payment methods and digital wallets. Popular payment methods include debit/credit cards, bank transfers, USSD codes, and mobile money. The payment system of e-commerce in Nigeria has evolved significantly in recent years to accommodate the growing digital economy. Several factors have contributed to the development of payment systems in Nigeria’s e-commerce sector, including increased internet penetration, improved financial infrastructure, and the adoption of mobile technology. Here’s a detailed discussion of the payment system of e-commerce in Nigeria:

1. Credit Cards: Debit and credit cards, such as Visa, Mastercard, and local Nigerian cards, are widely accepted on e-commerce platforms. Many online shoppers prefer card payments due to their convenience and security.

2. Bank Transfers: Bank transfers are a common method of payment in Nigeria’s e-commerce sector. Customers can make payments directly from their bank accounts to the seller’s account. Some e-commerce platforms offer instant bank transfers for seamless transactions.

3. Mobile Money: Mobile money services, such as MTN Mobile Money, Airtel Money, and 9Mobile’s 9Pay, are popular among consumers who do not have traditional bank accounts. These services allow users to store and transfer money using their mobile phones.

4. USSD Codes: Unstructured Supplementary Service Data (USSD) codes are widely used for mobile payments in Nigeria. Customers can access their bank accounts and make transactions by dialing specific USSD codes on their mobile phones. This method is accessible even on basic mobile phones.

5. Digital Wallets: Some e-commerce platforms and financial institutions offer digital wallets that users can fund and use for online transactions. Examples include Paga, Flutterwave’s Barter, and Opay’s Owallet.

4. LOGISTICS Challenges: Despite the growth, logistical challenges such as unreliable postal services, inadequate transportation infrastructure, and security concerns can affect e-commerce operations. Companies have been developing innovative ways to address these challenges, including building their own logistics networks. Logistics challenges in e-commerce in Nigeria present significant obstacles to the growth and efficiency of the industry. While e-commerce has grown rapidly in the country, logistics-related issues can hinder the seamless delivery of products to customers. Here’s a discussion of some of the key logistics challenges in e-commerce in Nigeria.

1.     Poor Transportation Infrastructure: Nigeria faces issues with inadequate road networks, which can lead to delays and increased transportation costs for e-commerce businesses. Many roads are poorly maintained, leading to longer delivery times and potential damage to goods in transit.

2.     Last-Mile Delivery Challenges: The “last mile” of delivery, from a distribution center to the customer’s doorstep, can be particularly problematic in Nigeria. Inefficient addressing systems, limited access to certain areas, and congested urban areas can make last-mile delivery a logistical headache.

3.     Traffic Congestion; Major Nigerian cities, like Lagos and Abuja, often experience heavy traffic congestion. This congestion can lead to delays in delivering packages, increased fuel costs, and difficulties in scheduling deliveries.

4.     Security Concerns: Theft and security concerns are prevalent, both in transit and during last-mile deliveries. E-commerce companies need to implement robust security measures to protect their shipments.

 

6. Formation of Online Contracts: In Nigeria, online contracts are governed by contract law, and they are legally binding if certain conditions are met. These conditions include offer and acceptance, intention to create legal relations, certainty of terms, and the capacity of parties involved. It is primarily knowledge that there is generally no specific form in which a contract maybe entered into. The court succinctly put it this was; ‘it is elementary law that a contract maybe demonstrated by the conduct of the parties as well as by their words and deeds or by the document that have passed between them’’. Thus a contract may be entered into either orally, in writing or indeed by conduct. By extension, a contract may also be brought into existence electronically by online communication, a process which we call online contract. An online contract has been define as ‘’…a contract created wholly or in part through communications over computer network.’’ examples are contracts entered into by email, through websites, via electronic data interchange etc. contracts maybe formed online where the parties exchange emails which consist of an offer and acceptance. it is also possible for the ingredients of the contract to be partly by exchange of emails or other forms of electronic communication, paper document, faxes and oral discussions, phone calls and text message etc contract may also be formed via websites and similar online services. Online contract can also be possibly formed where an electronic content is offered online and a user downloads such content, a contract then comes into being without a formal agreement. Again, online contract can be entered or made not just via electronic mails or correspondence but also by electronic communication on electronic platforms such as online instant messaging application such as Whatsapp, Facebook, etc.

a)     Offer and acceptance in online contract: online contract like most other contract may be either unilateral [contract of adhesion] or bilateral. The contract is unilateral when it is a non negotiated agreement entered into electronically and is actually a proposed contract that becomes binding if assent is obtained. Majority of online contract are of this nature and are therefore contracts of adhesion as the buyer often does not possess any bargaining power over the terms and condition put up by the seller and the former is caged into a situation of take-it-or-leave-it. A bilateral contract is one where the parties negotiate and may be entered into either online or offline. Acceptance in an online contract may be in any form which shows that the offeree has clearly and unequivocally accepted the term of the offer. This may be done or effected offline by written or oral communications as well as by conduct. Acceptance is also effective online by email, or other form of electronic message, and by conduct such as clicking on a button or downloading content. In online contract there is no other option to contract except by communication through the internet. There is some controversy as to the validity of some offer and acceptance by computers in situation where there is no human involvement because of the issues of existence of contractual intention which is raised. State Farm Mutual Auto Ins. Co. V. Bockhurst the court held that the computer operates only in accordance with the information and directions supplied by its programmers. this means that there is human intention to create legal relation in the computer transactions.

The provision of Section 153[2] Of The Evidence Act 2011 is worth nothing to the effect that an email is presumed correct as fed into the sender’s computer for transmission but there is no presumption that it has been received or that its contents were exactly as fed into the computer by the sender. Where an offer or acceptance is sent by email, actual receipt in exact form sent is required for a contract to result.

b)    Clickwrap and Browsewrap Agreements: Websites may include “clickwrap” agreements where users must explicitly click “I agree” to terms and conditions before proceeding with a purchase. “Browsewrap” agreements, on the other hand, rely on users’ implied acceptance of terms through website use. Courts have examined the enforceability of these agreements.

c)     Consumer Protection: The Federal Competition And Consumer Protection Act,2018 [FCCPA] to promote and protect the interest of consumers over all product and services. Many jurisdictions have consumer protection laws that require businesses to provide clear and transparent contract terms. This includes disclosing key terms such as pricing, return policies, and cancellation rights.

d)    Electronic Signatures: Laws such as the Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act (ESIGN) in the United States and the eIDAS Regulation in the European Union recognize electronic signatures as legally binding. These laws facilitate the use of electronic contracts in e-commerce. There is no specified format for e-signatures under Nigeria law. However, under Section 93 [3]of the Evidence Act, an e-signature is defined as being used when the person has executed a symbol or security procedures to verify the authorship of an electronic record.

Under Section 93 Of The Evidence Act 2011, where a rule of evidence requires or provides certain consequences if a document is not signed, an electronic signature satisfies that rule of law or avoids those consequences. In addition, under Section 17[1] Of The Cybercrime Act 2015, electronic signatures are binding in purchases of goods and other commercial transactions.

CONCLUSION

e-commerce and online contracts are a rapidly evolving area of commercial law. The legal Framework governing online transactions continues to adapt to the changing landscape of digital commerce, balancing the interests of businesses, consumers, and regulatory authorities. Legal professionals and businesses engaged in e-commerce must stay informed about the evolving legal requirements and best practices to ensure compliance and mitigate legal risks.

 

]]>
https://1stattorneys.ng/articles/2023/11/17/e-commerce-and-online-contract-in-nigeria/feed/ 0